SHARE THE ROAD?
“Share-the- Road” Signs,
bumper stickers and license plate messages
have been promoting the idea that enhanced bicycle safety could be achieved
through education and public awareness, public support for bike lanes, etc., for
as long as I can remember. As an
example, we know that the push for a “Share-The-Road”Florida State Specialty
license plate goes back to 1992 when the idea was born and the pressure to get
the state approval grew steadily for the next eight years till, finallty, in
the spring of 2000, a Florida State “Share the road” specialty license plate
was available for purchase. Other states of the nation have also adopted pro
cycling, pro sharing the road license plates in one form or another. In
addition, Pro cycling organizations have also embraced this philosophy through
campaings of their own and it is probably safe to say that, by now, after more
than a decade of “Share The Road” promotions, most cyclists support it.
Unquestionably, the “intentions”
behind these efforts are honorable. We ALL want more safety for motorists and
cyclists. We all want to see a reduction of injuries and death. Yet, after all
these years, perhaps it is time to think about the effectiveness of the “Share
The Road” movement. Has it resulted in more considerate drivers? Have the
availability of more bike lanes and a plethora educational programs this
movement has inspired succeeded in significantly reducing the number of
cyclists that are killed on the road? The available statistics suggest that the
Share The Road philosophy has not succeeded. The chart below shows the number of
cyclists killed each year on US roads since the year 2000. It does not take long to see that in spite of
all the Share The Road “propaganda”, when bicycles and cars meet on the road,
the cyclists get killed at the same rate as they did long ago. It is as if bike lanes,
education and well meaning “Share The Road” thoughts have not made any
difference.
CYCLISTS KILLED ON US ROADS
2000 689
2001 739
2002 663
2003 626
2004 722
2005 784
2006 769
2007 699
2008 716
2009 628
2010 621
2011 680
2012 730
2013 741
The number of deaths has stayed the same but the number of cyclists has increased a great deal. Something is working.http://www.bikeleague.org/commutingdata
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMy article was not intended as a full blown study. For example, it does not list the number of injured cyclists and also does not point out that the number of motorists has also increased. As to the stats from the bikeleague.org, by their own admission, they are based on estimates from surveys and are subject to significant errors. My main point is that there are alternatives that actually work better than a painted line on a busy road. These alternatives cost money and they won't happen until we are willing to pay for it. Education can help increase awareness and help the public understand the value of these alternatives. But education won't be effective to reduce carelessness . The last point is debatable but I am very skeptical so it would take a ton of solid evidence to convince me that education cures carelessness! Sadlly, cycling is not valued in the US as much is it appears to be valued elsewhere and it does seem that we live in a "me first", "the devil made me do it" society where so many people try to avoid personal responsibility.
ReplyDelete